24-hour emergency locksmith service across Duval, Clay, St. Johns, Nassau & Baker counties · (904) 827-7496

The Keys Maker — home

24-Hour Locksmith in St. Augustine

From the old city to the island to the US-1 corridor, The Keys Maker covers St. Augustine with the same rule as everywhere else: the price on the phone before the van moves. Lockouts, rekeys, car keys, and historic-hardware work. Call (904) 827-7496.

24-hour emergency service
The price on the phone, before the drive.

Licensed & Insured

St. Johns County Lic. B.L1101834 · Hiscox insured

Background-Checked Techs

Every technician screened before wearing the name

Price Before the Drive

The phone quote is the price at the door

24-Hour Emergency Service

Duval, Clay, St. Johns, Nassau & Baker

Covering ZIPs 32084, 32080, 32086, 32092, and 32095 — downtown and the historic district, Anastasia Island, St. Augustine Beach, Vilano Beach, the US-1 corridor, and World Golf Village.

House lockout service in St. Augustine, FL
House lockout — St. Augustine

Locksmith Services in St. Augustine

Historic-district hardware. The blocks around St. George Street and the historic homes north and south of the plaza carry locks that aren’t a big-box part — mortise cases, skeleton-keyed doors, hardware older than the state’s road system. We repair and rebuild where it’s possible and match replacements where it isn’t, so the door keeps its character.

Salt on two fronts. Between the bay, the inlet, and the ocean side of Anastasia Island and Vilano, St. Augustine hardware corrodes from more directions than anywhere else we work. Seized locks and pitted cylinders are the standard local call.

Rentals and guest turnover. The vacation-rental stock on the island and around the old city turns over weekly. Rekeys, keyed-alike sets, and smart locks with expiring codes keep the keys from multiplying — smart locks.

Visitor lockouts. Keys locked in cars near the Castillo, the parking garages, and the beach lots — a steady part of the week here. From $85, damage-free.

Homes and businesses on the mainland. The neighborhoods off US-1 and SR 207 and out to World Golf Village get every service on this site, at the published prices.

Our Promise to St. Augustine

St. Augustine deserves a locksmith who respects what’s on its doors. Some of the hardware in the old city has outlived every business that ever serviced it, and the right answer there is repair and matching — not the fastest replacement in the van. My promise: an honest read on whether your lock is worth saving, coastal-rated parts when it isn’t, the price on the phone before we make the drive down, and an ETA that accounts for the real distance — we’re up the county, and you’ll never hear a fifteen-minute fantasy from us.

— Leah, Owner, The Keys Maker

Old City, Straight Answers

Call (904) 827-7496. In a city this old, "they don’t make them like they used to" is just a description of the front door. We work on those.

Hiring any locksmith — including us? The FTC’s advice is worth two minutes: use caution when seeking a locksmith.

Searching for a locksmith near me in Jacksonville, St. Johns, or anywhere across Duval, Clay, Nassau, and Baker counties? The Keys Maker is the local, licensed & insured answer — one call, a real price, and a van that’s actually from here: (904) 827-7496.

Frequently Asked Questions

Duval, Clay, St. Johns, Nassau, and Baker counties: Jacksonville and its neighborhoods, Julington Creek, Fruit Cove, Nocatee, Ponte Vedra, the CR 210 corridor, St. Johns, St. Augustine, Yulee, Callahan, Fernandina Beach on Amelia Island, and Macclenny. If you’re near the edge of that map, call — we’ll give you a straight yes or no.

As fast as the nearest van allows, and you’ll get the honest ETA on the phone. Inside northern St. Johns and south Jacksonville, that’s usually quick; we don’t quote fantasy minutes just to win the call.

You describe the job, we quote it, and that quote is the price you pay. If the job turns out bigger than described, work pauses and you approve the new number first. No trip-fee surprises, no upsell at the door.

Yes — The Keys Maker LLC is a licensed and insured Florida business (St. Johns County Business License No. B.L1101834), and every technician is background-checked. Worth knowing: Florida has no statewide locksmith trade license, which is exactly why you should ask any locksmith what stands behind the word. Ours is above — verify it with St. Johns County yourself.

Yes, for most makes and model years — cut and programmed on site from the vehicle itself, including transponder and proximity keys. No tow to a dealer required.

Rekeying keeps good hardware and changes which key works it — the right move after a move-in or lost keys. Replacement is for worn, damaged, or low-grade locks. We’ll tell you which one your door actually needs, and rekeying is usually the cheaper answer.

Yes — supply, install, and configure, or install one you already bought. We’ll also tell you honestly when a smart lock is the wrong fit for a door or a household.

Check the other doors, then call (904) 827-7496. Don’t break a window — the glass usually costs more than the locksmith. You’ll get a price and an ETA on the same call, at 2 PM or 2 AM.

Warning signs: a $19 or $29 phone quote that triples on arrival, an unmarked car, no company name on the phone, cash-only pressure, and drilling as the first suggestion. A real local shop gives a firm quote, shows up marked, and can prove who they are.

After the work is done, at the quoted price. Card or cash both work. You’ll never be asked to pay before you’re back inside.

No — emergencies are the loud half. The quiet half is scheduled work: rekeys, lock upgrades, smart locks, master key systems, and new-home lock changes, booked at your convenience, evenings and weekends included.

Yes. One key for the owner, limited keys for staff, and a plan for what gets rekeyed when someone leaves. We build it around how your business actually runs.

Usually not. The fragment comes out with extraction tools, the lock gets checked, and in most cases you just need a fresh key. Don’t dig at it with tweezers — that’s how a cheap fix becomes a replacement.

Rarely. Non-destructive entry is always the first approach; drilling is the last resort for certain high-security cylinders, and you’ll approve it — and the replacement cost — before it happens.

He’ll confirm he’s from The Keys Maker and the price you were quoted. Ask for the company name before you open up — any honest tech expects the question. If anything feels off, call us back on (904) 827-7496 and we’ll confirm who’s standing there.

Salt air corrodes pins, springs, and finishes from the inside out — beach-side hardware can age a decade in a few summers. A yearly clean and graphite lubrication helps; when a coastal lock starts grinding, replace it before it seizes on a Sunday night.

Let's Talk About Your Security

One call covers it: a straight answer, a real price, and a technician who works your county every day. Emergency service runs 24 hours a day; scheduled work is booked at your convenience, evenings and weekends included. Shop visits by appointment.

Serving Duval, Clay, St. Johns, Nassau & Baker Counties

Jacksonville · Julington Creek · Fruit Cove · Nocatee · Ponte Vedra · St. Johns · the CR 210 corridor · St. Augustine · Mandarin · San Marco · Southside · Orange Park · Fleming Island · Yulee · Callahan · Fernandina Beach & Amelia Island · Macclenny — and the neighborhoods in between. Area pages are coming online one by one; until yours is live, the phone works everywhere: contact us or call (904) 827-7496.

The Keys Maker LLC · Licensed & Insured · 35 Durbin Station Court, Unit 105, St. Johns, FL 32259 · 24-hour emergency locksmith service across Duval, Clay, St. Johns, Nassau & Baker; shop visits by appointment. About us.

Locksmith Work Van in Front of Keys Maker Office 35 Durbin Statio in St. Johns, FL
Our van covers five counties — Duval, Clay, St. Johns, Nassau & Baker